Trader Interviews HomeTrader Interviews Premium MembershipTrader Interviews Premium LoginTrader Interviews FAQsInterviews with Top TradersTrader Interviews Live EventsAbout Tim, Trader Interviews HostTrader Idea Lab





 » FAQ
 » Home
 » Submit an Idea
 » Join IdeaLab
 » Lost Password
 » Contact Us
 » User List
 
Buy 2 Buys
Sell 1 Sell

When to Take a Profit Early?

Subscribe to this Idea

This is an area of my system I have contemplated and have not found a consistent rule for. I would like everyone's opinion, (granted only about 5 people ever participate in this idea lab, I value everyones opinion greatly.)

While target prices are subjective, I find myself pulling the trigger early on a portion of the position (to lock in profits) or letting  a bounce get away from me and fall back close to my stop price. So...

Do I take some off the table when my profit reaches a certain number no matter what (say at $200 profit i always sell 1/4 of my positon)? Or do I hold more of my position letting the winners exceed the losers that started as winners? I'd love some input!

- tim

Submitter: MustangCarter MustangCarter (Ideas, comments)
Category: Stocks
  1. 0 Buys, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    This is the very same point I'm at with the system I'm using. I'm absolutely confident in the systems ability to create great entry points but knowing how far to let the profits run is always difficult. I'd suggest doing a statistical study of your own past trades using the system. You're very likely to find some common areas of resistance (or support if shorting) that tend to hold in your unique situation which you can use to take partials/exit. When you know the probability of your winners running to 2R, 3R etc versus the win/loss ratio (obviously this will become smaller as you increase the R value) you can then decide whether you're comfortable letting them run further (if the statistics suggest it's a good idea)
  2. 0 Buys, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    I can get a fairly good idea of a stocks range of movement (as a percentage), based on looking at a chart. For longer term swing trades, I set my targets as a percent from my entry point. I would only take profits if it broke my trailing stop (from some set moving average, not the price) before reaching the profit target.

    For day trades, my method is different. I work off of pivot points to find an entry point. I am now familiar enough with the stocks I day trade to know how far the price usually will run from the pivot point. I only day trade stocks that I have watched and have an understanding of their typical behavior.

    http://acekingtrader.blogspot.com

    http://www.pivotpointcalculator.com
  3. 0 Buys, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    I will say that hte trading volume begins to diminih and the candle sticks begin to shorten and at the top the round shape of hte head is to begin to form it is the time to exit.
  4. 1 Buy, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    Exit strategies are often overlooked. In most systems entries get all the attention, but exits will often determine your profitability.

    If you're looking for something mechanical, there are several indicators that work great for stops. SAR is a good one as it tightens up your stop the longer your trade runs. Trailing stops using multiples of ATR is a very popular method. Fibo levels or pivots are powerful exit targets. I will usually exit all or part of a position when price stalls at a trendline or S&R;.

    For something discretionary, You'll just have to use the same methods you use for entering. One thing I've used is to ask myself, "Would I enter a trade in the opposite direction?". If yes, I exit my existing position. Scaling out is an excellent way to relieve some of the stress you are experiencing. Most traders I know of who are trading any real volume, scale in and out of their positions. Unless there is a strong reversal signal, it can be wise to let a small portion of your positions run after moving your stop loss to break even or even locking in a profit. On a strong tend day, I've made more profit from that small portion I let run rather than all my scalps combined.
  5. 0 Buys, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    I always go for trailing stops. Anything above that stop can never be mine. I try to trail using short term bounces. In this if my stop is taken away I am happy. But then I will again reenter in same stock or currancy pair if my entry rules allows me.
  6. 0 Buys, 0 Sells rate down rate up
    I always go for trailing stops. Anything above that stop can never be mine. I try to trail using short term bounces. In this if my stop is taken away I am happy. But then I will again reenter in same stock or currancy pair if my entry rules allows me.
Log In or Join Trader Interviews for free to comment on this idea.